Tube Question

This forum is dedicated to discussions about tube radios and tube amplifiers.
Post Reply
User avatar
Slim Pickins
Donor
Donor
Posts: 898
Joined: November 8th, 2009, 7:10 am
Handle: Slim Pickins
Real Name: Paul
Call Sign: VE1PEW
Radio: Realistic Navajo 457
Contact:

Tube Question

#277777

Post by Slim Pickins »

I have been looking at a few sites and suppliers for tubes. I have a few in my radio that tested very low on the good to very high on the week scale on the tube tester at a local shop. As an example I have seen 12AX7 tubes ranging in price from $7-$115. The descriptions range almost as much with some saying "strong highs and mid-ranges" to "strong base and low range". Some don't specify any particular use others say things like good replacement tube for Marshall Guitar Amp.
Will any one of these tubes work in my radio or are certain ones recommended for radio use. I have a week 12AX7 which in my radio is the 1st audio/Modulator/Mic Preamp, which might explain why I need the mic gain almost all the way up to be heard. Would it be better to have one more tailored to having strong base rather than highs and mid-ranges. I would think most male voices fall into the bass category.
I guess what I am asking is, are all tubes of the same number compatible? Obviously they are not all created equal or there wouldn't be such a price difference.

Thanks
Paul
73,Slim

Insanity is hereditary......you get it from your children.
User avatar
4 cycle
Skipshooter
Skipshooter
Posts: 319
Joined: January 26th, 2008, 8:39 am
Handle: 4 CYCLE
Real Name: JOSEPH
Radio: MESSENGER 223
Contact:

Re: Tube Question

#277829

Post by 4 cycle »

All you need to worry about is if the tube tests good a 12AX7 tube is used in old TV sets, Radios, Amplifiers what ever, as long as it tests good it should work or for some tubes there are substitutes if the origonal is not available. Try KENS ELECTRONICS hes got that tube and hundreds more .That one is $11.00 Keep that tube stuff working , they are much better than todays pieces of SH -- OOPS TECHNOLOGY IMO. All my radios are 40 or more years old ! :biggrin: PS WHEN A TUBE TESTS WEAK ITS TIME TO REPLACE IT AND YES TUBES WITH THE SAME NUMBERS ARE COMPATABLE!
Last edited by 4 cycle on May 5th, 2010, 11:16 am, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Night Crawler
Wordwide & Qualified
Wordwide & Qualified
Posts: 3,836
Joined: May 15th, 2007, 9:03 am
Contact:

Re: Tube Question

#277833

Post by Night Crawler »

Slim Pickins wrote: As an example I have seen 12AX7 tubes ranging in price from $7-$115. The descriptions range almost as much with some saying "strong highs and mid-ranges" to "strong base and low range". Some don't specify any particular use others say things like good replacement tube for Marshall Guitar Amp.
4 cycle wrote:All you need to worry about is if the tube tests good
That's right don't spend a lot of money for that tube.

The typical cb has a frequency response between 300hz to 3000hz due to the interstage coupling caps used in the speech amplifier and modulator.

You don't have to worry about getting a tube for high fidelity like used in a guitar amp or stereo.
User avatar
Slim Pickins
Donor
Donor
Posts: 898
Joined: November 8th, 2009, 7:10 am
Handle: Slim Pickins
Real Name: Paul
Call Sign: VE1PEW
Radio: Realistic Navajo 457
Contact:

Re: Tube Question

#277879

Post by Slim Pickins »

Thanks for the responses.

Paul
73,Slim

Insanity is hereditary......you get it from your children.
User avatar
'Doc

Re: Tube Question

#277883

Post by 'Doc »

All tubes made by different manufacturers are not the same every time. there can be some very slight difference, or the differences can make a huge difference depending on how they are used. For instance. Some 572B tubes can be used in an SB-200 and some can't. The difference in that particular instance is the way the tube is put together. Some have the filament/grid/plate structure facing vertically, while others have it facing horizontally. Those with the horizontal grids shouldn't be laid down like in the SB-200, the grid sags and shorts to the plate. Or maybe I said that the wrong way around, the horizontal/vertical structure thingy. You get the idea anyway.
There are differences in most tubes by different manufacturers, most of the time those difference don't make a lot of difference, but they certainly can.
- 'Doc
User avatar
721HACKSAW
Donor
Donor
Posts: 1,557
Joined: February 25th, 2008, 10:43 am

Re: Tube Question

#277905

Post by 721HACKSAW »

Doc is right, there are differences in tubes depending on thier origin of manufacture or how they are used. The Yaesu 101 was originally designed to use a Japanese made 6JS6C, you don't want to use a 6JS6C that was manufactured in the U.S. without making a capacitor change.
Post Reply